A baby is dead. A family is grieving. And somewhere, someone is warming up their typing fingers to explain how this could never happen to them.
I wish I had that much faith in myself.
Ten-month-old Scottie Crowell died after being left in a car in Kentucky. Police say her grandmother, a doctor, was supposed to take her to daycare but instead went to work, forgetting the baby was still in the vehicle. A grand jury has since declined to indict her, finding insufficient probable cause.
I read that story and felt sick. For the baby. For her parents. And yes, for the grandmother. I'm a Nan. I can't imagine what that would be like. Even if your daughter could forgive you; your son-in-law would never be able to. Myself, I could never forgive myself.
That is why I’m struggling with the rush to condemn.
People hear “forgot the baby” and assume it means “didn’t care about the baby”. I don’t think we can make that leap from a headline. The consequence is unbearable. That doesn’t tell us everything about the person who made the mistake.
I never put a baby’s stroller behind the car. It’s one of my rules, because I can imagine getting distracted, getting into the driver’s seat and doing something dreadful. I take that precaution because I know I can make mistakes.
Most of us have had a moment when we’ve thought, Shit!!! I almost left my baby. Then it didn’t. We got the chance to learn, change a habit and carry on. Some people don’t get that chance. My own mother walked me around to the shops and went home. When she walked in my Grandmother said "where is the baby?!!" at which point my mother bolted back to the shop. I was waiting there, unharmed!
None of this makes a child’s death less serious. Scottie should be alive. Her parents should have their baby. Compassion for her grandmother does not take a single thing away from that.
Nor does it mean every case should escape investigation. This one was investigated. The grand jury’s proceedings are confidential, so the public does not have all the evidence it considered.
What I do know is that a grieving family gains nothing from strangers competing to write the cruellest comment. I’d rather this story made us check the back seat, confirm a child arrived safely and build precautions into our routines.
“I’d never” is a comforting thought, but it isn’t much of a safety plan.